Recurrent Miscarriages

Dr. Panagiotis Polyzos, obstetrician gynecologist in Athens
Dr. Panagiotis Polyzos MD PhD MSc

Obstetrician-Gynecologist
PhD, University of Athens Medical School

Obstetrician-gynecologist Panagiotis Polyzos practices at the Institute of Life, the IVF Unit of IASO Maternity Hospital.

Contents

Recurrent Miscarriage

Recurrent Miscarriages

What are recurrent miscarriages?

Pregnancy loss causes physical and emotional distress for couples, especially when it occurs repeatedly (recurrent miscarriages), and they certainly need support and psychological assistance from their environment (family, friends), as well as from the medical and nursing staff responsible for their care.

Spontaneous pregnancy loss is unfortunately a common phenomenon. Approximately 15% of clinically recognized pregnancies end in miscarriage, while a fairly large number of pregnancies are lost before they even become clinically detectable.

Historically, the term recurrent miscarriages refers to 2–3 consecutive pregnancy losses before 20 weeks, with a frequency of 1 in 300 pregnancies and affecting 1%–2% of women of reproductive age. Although the guideline suggests performing the relevant evaluation after the third miscarriage, in practice it is often necessary even after the first one, depending on the case.

How is the evaluation for recurrent miscarriages performed?

The evaluation for recurrent miscarriages includes a detailed medical history, clinical and ultrasound examination, as well as chromosomal and specific histopathological examination of the miscarriage tissue, which may reveal findings associated with specific causes of miscarriages.

(e.g., immunological, thrombophilic) and guide further laboratory testing.

What are the causes of recurrent miscarriages?

The etiology of recurrent miscarriages is usually multifactorial and includes genetic causes, anatomical abnormalities of the uterus, endocrine disorders, immune causes, thrombophilic disorders, infections, environmental factors, and unknown causes.

Genetic causes

About 2% to 4% of recurrent miscarriages are linked to balanced chromosomal abnormalities in the parents and, depending on the specific diagnosis (karyotype of the couple), treatment includes in vitro fertilization with preimplantation genetic testing.

Anatomical abnormalities of the uterus

10% to 15% of recurrent miscarriages are linked to anatomical abnormalities of the uterus, which are diagnosed by hysterosalpingography and/or hysteroscopy while the treatment is surgical.

Endocrine causes

Approximately 17%–20% of recurrent miscarriages are associated with endocrine factors (e.g., diabetes mellitus, thyroid disorders, etc.), diagnosed through specific laboratory tests, and managed with medication.

Find a solution to your problem.
Schedule your appointment

Immunological causes

Pregnancy represents an “immunological paradox,” since although the fetus is not genetically identical to the mother, she does not reject it but protects it through complex immunological mechanisms. Possible abnormalities in these mechanisms are related to single or recurrent miscarriages. Diagnosis is carried out with blood tests and specific examination of the miscarriage tissue, many of which are treatable, improving the live birth outcomes.

Thrombophilic causes

Thrombophilia is classified into inherited (15% of the population) and acquired, or a combination of both.

Diagnosis is performed through specialized blood tests, and treatment is pharmacological.

Infections

Certain infections (toxoplasmosis, rubella, etc.) have been associated with single miscarriages and essentially not with recurrent miscarriages (0.2%–0.5%).

Environmental factors

At times, single or recurrent miscarriages have been linked to exposure to various harmful factors. In any case, pregnant women should avoid smoking, alcohol, and caffeine.

MEDIA

Follow us on YouTube

Prenatal screening during pregnancy
Interview on the TRT show “Kentriki Ellada Kalispera” (Good Evening, Central Greece)

Unexplained recurrent miscarriages

20%–30% of recurrent miscarriages remain unexplained and are treated empirically.

The prognosis for recurrent miscarriages is individualized and depends on the causes and the number of miscarriages. Overall, it is encouraging, considering that even after four consecutive miscarriages, the probability of a successful pregnancy is 60%–65%.

It is also worth noting that several causes of recurrent miscarriages — particularly those related to early miscarriage — may be associated with infertility and failed assisted reproduction attempts. In the context of investigating and treating infertility, histopathological examination of an endometrial biopsy, collected during diagnostic hysteroscopy, can play an important role.

Finally, it should be emphasized that both recurrent miscarriage cases and infertility cases involve multiple medical specialties, with one sole purpose, to help these truly burdened couples achieve a healthy baby!

In recurrent miscarriages due to chromosomal abnormalities, IVF with preimplantation genetic testing of the embryos may be recommended.

Recurrent miscarriage: what has changed in current guidelines

In the past, testing began after three consecutive miscarriages. The most recent guidelines of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) and the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) define recurrent miscarriage as two or more pregnancy losses, which do not have to be consecutive. The reason is simple: couples should not have to go through a third loss to get answers.

The second major change concerns what we test for. Instead of a long list of tests “just to be sure,” the guidelines separate the tests that actually change treatment from those that only add cost and anxiety. A result with no treatment consequence does not help the couple.

Third, age matters too. The mother's age is the strongest known risk factor, because the share of eggs with chromosomal abnormalities rises over the years. That’s why in women over 35, testing should not be delayed.

Which tests are worthwhile and which are not

Recommended

  • Antiphospholipid antibodies: lupus anticoagulant, anticardiolipin and anti-beta2 glycoprotein I. They are repeated after 12 weeks if positive.
  • Thyroid: TSH and TPO antibodies.
  • Uterine anatomy: ideally a 3D transvaginal ultrasound. If there is a suspicious finding, it is followed by hysteroscopy.
  • Genetic analysis of the pregnancy tissue: if a chromosomal abnormality is found in the embryo, the loss is explained and the outlook for the next pregnancy is usually good.
  • Parental karyotype: in selected cases, e.g. when the pregnancy tissue shows an unbalanced chromosomal abnormality.

Not recommended routinely

  • Inherited thrombophilia testing without a personal or family history of thrombosis.
  • Natural killer (NK) cell measurements, HLA typing and cytokines.
  • Repeated hormone measurements without a clinical indication.

Testing the male partner should not be skipped. His age, smoking and sperm DNA fragmentation may contribute, and the investigation is done together with an assessment for male infertility where needed.

Antiphospholipid syndrome: the most treatable cause

Antiphospholipid syndrome is an autoimmune condition in which the body produces antibodies that promote blood clotting and affect how the placenta works. Diagnosis requires a combination of history and persistently positive tests, not a single isolated measurement.

Treatment is simple and evidence-based: low-dose aspirin from the time you start trying to conceive, and low molecular weight heparin injections from the moment the pregnancy is confirmed. With this treatment, the chances of a live birth improve significantly.

Women with antiphospholipid syndrome need close monitoring throughout pregnancy, because they have a higher risk of preeclampsia, fetal growth restriction and preterm birth. Treatment usually continues for about six weeks after delivery as well, to prevent blood clots.

Evidence-based treatments and treatments that are not recommended

Many “treatments” without evidence circulate for recurrent miscarriage. Knowing the difference protects the couple from unnecessary injections, cost and false hope.

Evidence-based, for the right indications

  • Aspirin and heparin in antiphospholipid syndrome.
  • Vaginal micronized progesterone in women with a previous miscarriage who have bleeding early in a new pregnancy. In the large PRISM trial, the benefit was greater in those with three or more previous miscarriages.
  • Levothyroxine when hypothyroidism is present.
  • Blood sugar control before conception in women with diabetes.
  • Hysteroscopic removal of intrauterine adhesions or polyps that distort the cavity. For a uterine septum, the data are conflicting and the decision is individualized.

No proven benefit

  • Heparin in unexplained miscarriages or in inherited thrombophilia without a history of thrombosis.
  • Intravenous immunoglobulins, intralipids, corticosteroids “for NK cells.”
  • Immunotherapy with the partner's lymphocytes.
  • Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy in unexplained miscarriages. By contrast, it does have a role when one parent carries a balanced chromosomal translocation.

The next pregnancy: monitoring from the first weeks

After repeated losses, a positive test often brings more fear than joy. Organized monitoring from early on helps both medically and emotionally.

  • Contact your doctor as soon as the test is positive, to start the treatment that has been agreed.
  • First transvaginal ultrasound at around 6 to 7 weeks, to confirm an intrauterine pregnancy and cardiac activity.
  • Follow-up every 1 to 2 weeks until you pass the gestational age of the previous losses.
  • Folic acid 400 mcg daily, stopping smoking and alcohol, caffeine up to about 200 mg a day.

In studies, supportive care with frequent contact and access to the team was linked to better emotional well-being in women. Psychological support from a specialist is worth offering to both partners.

When to go to the hospital right away

  • Bleeding that soaks one pad an hour for two hours in a row.
  • Severe pain on one side of the abdomen, shoulder pain or feeling faint, which may signal an ectopic pregnancy.
  • Fever, chills or foul-smelling vaginal discharge after a miscarriage, because they suggest an infection.

Myths and facts about recurrent miscarriage

After a loss, almost every woman looks for what she did “wrong.” Most of the time, the answer is: nothing.

  • “It's because of stress at work.” Everyday stress has not been shown to cause miscarriage. It is worth addressing for your own well-being, not because it makes you to blame.
  • “Exercise and sex are dangerous.” In a normal pregnancy, they do not increase the risk of miscarriage. Restrictions are given only for specific medical reasons.
  • “Bed rest prevents miscarriage.” There is no such evidence, while immobility increases the risk of blood clots.
  • “Air travel causes miscarriage.” No. Ordinary travel is not linked to pregnancy loss.
  • “Since I lost two, I will lose the next one too.” Most women with recurrent miscarriage eventually have a baby, even when no cause is found.

Removing the guilt is not just comfort. It is medical information that helps you focus on what actually changes the outcome.

Weight, habits and the role of both partners

Some lifestyle factors are linked to a higher risk of miscarriage and, unlike age, they can be changed.

  • Body weight: both obesity and very low weight are associated with a higher risk. Even moderate weight loss before conception improves metabolism and ovarian function.
  • Smoking: by both partners. Smoking by the man harms the quality of sperm DNA.
  • Alcohol: there is no safe limit when you are trying to conceive.
  • Caffeine: up to about 200 mg a day, that is one to two cups of coffee.
  • Occupational exposure: solvents, heavy metals, certain pesticides. Discuss it with your doctor if you work in such an environment.

These changes are not a “treatment” on their own. However, they add to the medical care and are within the couple's control.

The emotional toll of repeated losses

Repeated pregnancy loss is grief, even if the pregnancy lasted only a few weeks. Studies show that a significant share of women have symptoms of anxiety, depression or post-traumatic stress in the months after a miscarriage. Partners are affected too, often silently.

Seek help from a mental health professional if:

  • the sadness does not ease after several weeks or affects your work and sleep,
  • you have persistent feelings of guilt or flashbacks to the event,
  • you avoid pregnant women, babies or your gynecologist,
  • fear keeps you from considering a new pregnancy.

There is no “right” time to try again. Medically, after an early miscarriage a long wait is usually not required, as long as the testing has been completed. Emotional readiness carries the same weight.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is it considered recurrent miscarriage?

After two or more pregnancy losses. That is when testing of the couple begins.

Karyotype of both partners, testing for antiphospholipid syndrome, thyroid, blood sugar, assessment of the uterine cavity and, where possible, genetic analysis of the pregnancy tissue.

No. In about half of couples the tests are normal. Even then, the chance of a successful next pregnancy is high.

Even after three miscarriages, about six to seven out of ten women have a baby in the next pregnancy.

It may benefit women with previous miscarriages who have bleeding early in a new pregnancy. It is given only on medical advice.

No, ordinary everyday stress, mild or moderate exercise and sex have not been shown to cause miscarriage. Most early losses are due to chromosomal abnormalities in the embryo.

No. The combination of aspirin and heparin has a proven benefit in antiphospholipid syndrome. In unexplained miscarriages or inherited thrombophilia without a history of thrombosis, large studies did not show an improvement in births.

Yes. The man's karyotype is checked when indicated, while older age, smoking and high sperm DNA fragmentation have been associated with pregnancy loss.

Usually at around 6 to 7 weeks from your last period, when the embryo's cardiac activity can be seen. Earlier, the ultrasound often does not give a clear answer and increases anxiety.

CONTACT Call Us